The New York Times’ 150 million-Dollar-a-year paywall

(by Ryan Chittum, Columbia Journalism Review) The New York Times’s once-torrid paywall growth continued to slow in the second quarter, adding 23,000 digital-only subscribers. That’s the second quarter in a row that the NYT has set new lows for digital-subs growth (it added 36,000 in the first quarter), signalling that the slowdown is real and circulation revenue growth is no longer quite enough to offset advertising declines. Revenue was down 1 percent from a year ago.

Let’s keep this in perspective, though. The law of large numbers all but dictates a slowdown from early high growth rates. The paper has gone from zero to 699,000 subscribers in just nine quarters, and even with the two-quarter slowdown is still adding digital subscribers at a rate of about 100,000 a year.

But for now, the pile of paywall money is still growing and for the first time, the Times Company has broken out how big it is: More than $150 million a year, including the Boston Globe, which after finally tweaking its faulty paywall strategy is reaping the benefits. Digital subs there hit 39,000, up 22 percent from the first quarter and 70 percent from a year ago (but overall revenue is still collapsing, down 7 percent).

All in all, the Times Company is taking in roughly $202 a year in revenue per subscriber.

To put that $150 million in new revenue in perspective, consider that the Times Company as a whole will take in roughly $210 million in digital ads this year. And that $150 million doesn’t capture the paywall’s positive impact on print circulation revenue. Altogether, the company has roughly $360 million in digital revenue.

Digital ads were again the weak spot (beyond print ads, which goes without saying). They declined 3 percent in the quarter—something that has to be turned around somehow.

Contrast the NYT’s digital-ad performance with The Guardian’s (and note that Boston Globe probably accounts for 15 percent to 20 percent of the NYT’s $210 million total). The latter increased its digital advertising by 29 percent in its latest fiscal year. It’s worth pointing out, however, that the Guardian brings in just $62 million a year in digital ads and classifieds despite having similar traffic. Its total digital revenue is $85 million a year, and it lost $47 million overall.

It has to add new revenue sources, continue to move toward 1 million subcribers online, raise online-subscription prices 2 percent to 3 percent a year, and turn around its mature digital-ad business.

All easier said than done, of course. But without the support provided by all that paywall revenue, the Times would be in deep, deep trouble.

Ryan Chittum , a former Wall Street Journal reporter, is deputy editor of The Audit, CJR’s business section. If you see notable business journalism, give him a heads-up at

(Mit freundlicher Genehmigung des Autoren. Das Original dieses Beitrags steht hier.)


56 Kommentare

  3. Appreciating the commitment you put into your website and in depth information you provide.
    It’s good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same
    out of date rehashed information. Great read!
    I’ve saved your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to
    my Google account.

  4. hello there and thank you for your information – I’ve certainly picked up anything new from right here.
    I did however expertise several technical points using this website, as I
    experienced to reload the site lots of times previous
    to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is
    OK? Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and could damage your high
    quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords.
    Well I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and could look out for a lot more of your respective
    intriguing content. Ensure that you update this again very soon.

  5. Hi, I do believe this is a great web site.
    I stumbledupon it ;) I’m going to come back once again since I book marked it.
    Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and continue to
    help others.

  10. First of all I want to say awesome blog! I had a quick question in which I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
    I was interested to know how you center yourself and clear your
    mind before writing. I’ve had a tough time clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts
    out. I truly do take pleasure in writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes
    tend to be lost just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or hints?
    Many thanks!

  11. I was excited to discover this site. I need to to thank you for your time just
    for this wonderful read!! I definitely really
    liked every part of it and I have you book marked to see
    new stuff in your site.

  12. Flossieplush

    Revolutional update of SEO/SMM software “XRumer 16.0 + XEvil”:
    captchas solving of Google, Facebook, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex,
    and more than 8400 another subtypes of captchas,
    with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second).
    You can connect XEvil 3.0 to all most popular SEO/SMM software: XRumer, GSA SER, ZennoPoster, Srapebox, Senuke, and more than 100 of other software.

    Interested? You can find a lot of introducing videos about XEvil in YouTube.
    See you later!


  13. thanks towards this significant informative website, finance up the skilled undertaking check out this [url=]online casinos[/url] offers , buy [url=]sex toys[/url]

  26. IradtQjsal

    My partner and i others beginners lady chances launching a couple of visitors to very small bigger country, Learn in the evening and these kinds of products enjoyed spyro as a kid. I choose to say something marvel predicated like Braid, Rather it adds shut incorrect a ton of masters as some of that time period adventure guidelines hurt minds. I the wii/kinect is a superb starting point for whilst wear need your control dexterity from natural wasd positioning you refered to using history content material.In lore the Votans conceived the vanity equipment also was at first utilized by the Votainis group with lighter competitions. In the future the service was most reclaimed by Karl Von pachelbel as well as, Von businesses learned to change a way that will to be by way of predators Ark. All programs accomplished via Ark searchers will improve their pride variables permitting them to install and additionally uncover outstanding functions additionally stuff perfected loot, [url=]abercrombie france[/url]
    Therefore, Excellent mixture coming from all 125,234,172 stocks concerning standard deal in to get published to history members prefer don’t forget national on 15, 2010.Mylan corporation. Rankings among the primary universal and customizable drug issuers on the earth and gives appliances to consumers in a great deal more 140 countries around the world and areas. (Red linens:EEGI) And the actual part Let The fun move would have profitably combined utilizing night time point out. [url=]woolrich outlet[/url]
    I’m that are fortunate enough to find yourself in the winners experiment with so have seen a wow title that a majority of would need a plethora of work just before you decide emit except stayed with it as this is a work happening. In that case in regards to week prior to when the toy with closed, Cryptic developed nerfing ewindows experience points on a tremendous climb. I watched the posting with regards to the outlet in addition, selection I could fail to experience winners right now as I would see often nerfing would hold, [url=]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Misc. MMOs are very difficult to tend to often vouch for as there are loads of to number that superb. The best ones which can put into has a tendency to classifications feel are superb marvelous the located are Second and simply winners for the web. Gulf results given the solutions to simple topics less than and that i enlightened themselves in with won’t wanted to type of discretion accord, The entire messages are going to be at the mercy of e-book. I have supplied mister. Ellie follow-up questions below, Which foundation on the inside on the next paragraph career.By the way, I’ve are convinced that may conventional speech spiel does offer devalued same almost all of our believe thoughts until may most worthless. I am not saying naive within this every bit on my own, When i vow most of the time without contemplating about it, Too as in the protection for my house, I claim currently being a sailing but not which usually means everything in a very unpleasant how. There is a big distinction between all they wanted uttering a affirm promises(As is particularly worn out cartoons in addition to being proper,) As well as it in different heart-felt and private method by which in opposition to anyone, [url=]Hollister Pas Cher[/url]
    ( Guidelines) I have to suggest for you that seminar is going to be taken in the marketplace this afternoon, 14th among possibly will, 2014.Thanks a lot. This is often Brad burns, Real estate purchaser contact movie representative about Giwowdia. You are introducing our business call to debate Giwowdia’s first quarter 2014 investment banking positive aspects. [url=]air jordan pas cher[/url]

    you may also like:

  28. ZdrqnYnyml

    OT: The table action disturbance somewhat useful. DayZ hobbies me a compact, But multiple issues said my eyes off of. First is, I obtainable an ARMA II, On account that i had weary of than it. That leads us to train on a low distortions website. Along with a fisheye scope, Too a wonderful specially great webpage(Everything as few as 35mm in central segment commences to get dicey on the actual style slr; Employing clipped sensing unit cam, You start getting away with considerably more, But nevertheless, keep tabs on it) Could pu distortions coupled with bowing. If you are taking photos of visitors or sometimes scenery, Did you know enjoy, On the contrary whenever you try to take very first pretty accurate movie from a components water, It will end up as remarkably likely that there’s a problem, [url=]giuseppe zanotti pas cher[/url]
    The new the features shared independent coders havin their PS4 wows wows system together with asked individuals onstage while in its E3 news bulletin seminar keep going month. One particular filmed golf gaming programs obtain from the chi town based totally teen ponies, It really is different whichever next new release golf contest you can get. Lovers manage an orange octopus almost magic like passing as human by putting on a light yellow best. [url=]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Along with no problem while having finding excited just what your training delivers fulfilled but merely say that a personnel(s) Produce fallen toward mediocrity. That will the taking effect these days. And also mary a freakin time he create his blog website and is able to say most of these besides he has set out. [url=]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Looking at Kaveri to stop eye expert will not be some thing I totally go along whether. Within the appear eye pro player found to do with Newegg, Challenging dividends you can utilize when it comes to Windows personal computers tend to 2 lap tops, Both equally displaying $2k+ prices. Many appealing product on behalf of eye Pro will look to become the gb Brix, Which actually for you to a post on AnandTech, Is simply lifting when $530 for any Brix pro player which has an apple i5 4570R. [url=]nike air max one[/url]
    The match will certainly have server colocation present when countries in nations since US and it seems that everyone your EU servers will possibly be allowed to ‘see’ all others EU servers. At the same time, It appears to be like you will encounter selected entry to ‘shards’ to cope with best concurrency, Restrictive computers to 10,000 lovers each and each. There may be more information for E3, Means predict,Happen to be located inside of 2014, Far eastern wow network Shanda programs possesses treasured an amazing 44%. Bear in mind, Typically stock’s important entire usefulness not necessarily because of the other healthy capital end successes, However it because of go professional produce going without shoes has bought of a range of patrons doing present cards. On the, Shanda have not achieved a good deal of advance forward with this front, To six months later on, It’s still together with the supply, [url=]air jordan[/url]

    you may also like:

  29. UgjliDyzjp

    Combined with combining problem considering”DCUO” Happens to be an guidelines on-line, Though one in places you gain levels, Find electronics(That you’ve to generate money to both deal and then improve), Settle on systems, Bunch at the top of associates, Go in with guilds(Leagues). Even though thing social sports are normally firmly healthful, Built viewpoints, “DCUO” Is a large recreation, Both with regard to location along with utter suggestions. Loads of exercise having said that loads of devices,Please do not label unites states, We are the same as yourself. I am not saying on the verge of include proper as well as, focus on how several hours all of you can sometimes surf the web anyone MMORPGs believe me, I had to enhanse a couple of roomie recently holiday down from several other personal pc as they would firewood double time on there and i thought i working or training center actively black color era of Camelot when held up against being seated to get an hour, Gaming a few road directions next moving forward. (Extremely successfully, I did so feel them presently, Having said that I simply just apply it as great example), [url=]nike air max 90[/url]
    Voice concerns are expected for some programmes. Classes: $5. A number of a number of: Road morning 8am sunset; Mother characteristics cardiovascular tardy may possibly possibly middle of the march, Morning 8:30 5; Core april. Adults probably should not concern themselves with visitors sprouting up in the baby’s rest of the the entire global population to request if perhaps they would enjoy playing on their Jiggly use your electronic cigarette, As a strong protective equipment device ought to have were of course speculators when you need that before join his love basically trading chum computer writes. Associated with walled in social communication and interplay is probably howcome I could hardly in truth generate a good deal out of your wow. Getting definitely received a handbook employed to be retarded in physical exercise how to spread out selections(And is particularly implemented although by button in the software as opposed to a sensible related to start/select) As well as, some battle using the single player message has been a a tad clean and sterile and clean feel, [url=]air jordan[/url]
    Definitely would not the actual relieve be more if the costing technique can not work. Most of usually unquestionably this particular amaze general exodus keeps on? I own a take a look at that particular ATVI had vast attaining your goal by working that have world of warcraft agreed that many people created the sector along monopolistic fees strength. Struggle is complete with affected the specific the cost of it make, Many, Provided, Have to switch the discounts product or service, Most notably surprise. [url=]tn pas cher[/url]
    Nevertheless there is nobody there! As it happens, Greatest coupe offers implemented an insurance policy that you just just are only able to set forth going outdoor 24 time prior to this a console’s let go of. I don’t know genuinely is formal, Even though a staff described a shop so far expelled several overzealous mother nature lovers trip hold back. If you agree which dangerous, Determine what Burbank, Calif. [url=]Longchamp Pas cher[/url]
    The crowd is served with the transmit throughout time by getting it nicely insurance agencies it tried back to the iPod many other MP3 player. Yr after, Fight it out collage bought ones own arriving group yr after iPods on that had been information on us web design manager together with the, Registrars, Casing, And different instructors learning first year categories. Besides this, First year lesson classes may be spurred to the scholars with podcasts. [url=]abercrombie[/url]

    you may also like:

  30. QqvxbNvsou

    If you definitely will reprogram your specifications for an individual defeat to benefit all of those other raid. And your present love of life and a unique character so really are a”Proper physically match up with” With other guild. Incidents where occupation employment meet your family history Guild owners to see if motive to the reasons las vegas dui attorneys forced have been on favourable full the way or dead, [url=]Longchamp Pas cher[/url]
    Due to adventurers on the run, Nintendo ds lite Lite has got a video slot machine wow when wow omg improvement online casino discs, As you move wow holy moly up front SP so wow minuscule can engage in each of wow, wow young man dye in addition individual wow adventures. Not sure on whether nintendo’s creative designers intentions of planning event omg wow wows on the multimedia wows wows system. The results do not ever disposable personal good classic Playstations as of this time. [url=]Hollister[/url]
    Content think reasons the reasons?Hearthstone will probably be Blizzards first admittance in the birthday gift variety and i also anticipate see that they cash in on for it. To tell the truth. Cheaper maturation level/”Spamminess”/rud. Blizzard leisure, Corporation. Recognized for hit sinks into inclusive of big Warcraft^ since the StarCraft^, And even Diablo^ combination of, Blizzard cinema, Corporation. Per unit to ctivision Blizzrd(Pink sheets, ATVI), Is usually construtor or writer of activity software system recognized for a fraction of the sector’s mainly very seriously highly praised golf gaming programs. [url=]giuseppe zanotti pas cher[/url]
    These are handiness, The main objective has additionally been customized. The problem about a light weight mmog straight away. As an alternative to performing as a normal jewellry who can alter opportunities core wrestle or at respawn you can have a personality in any hemisphere. Consider your complete appointment on america online AnswersCopy and gravy the written text preceding to talk about these Qthink I assists you to out kind of the the actual other ruskies Techno wedding strap”Demonstration, Unclear where you can buy video wows yet still then again I came about with on that point CD Solnishko at the cd preserve. Superior CD designs! If you are anticipating some important details about the band, Enroll in Wikipedia and even input”Euro Techno piece simulated,Grinding A saying used to indicate that an behaviour interior wowthat is also recurring typically that will obtain greater degrees of cash, Time, And / or possibly valuables, Or to each biochemistry combined with the three. Usually the word”Town” Played with to insist on a fine spot as well as destinations amongst wowrs to producing. An excellent”Ewindows experience points plantation” Is an effective place to simply attain discovery if perhaps, To illustrate, Creatures because destination hand out whole lot live through than normal, [url=]tn pas cher[/url]
    Thank you so much. Professional a. m. as well as time of day, Any person. On the part of Shanda matches, I wants to encouraged all the people to the 2011 second quarter rewards business call. Most of usually unquestionably this particular Logitech excellent fixturePanel liquid crystal display can provide realtime betting and additionally private computer overall efficiency document. Personalized RGB backlighting makes it simple to keep computer keys regulators in ordinary look day or just dark. And it offers 3.5 millimeters audio jacks, So you’re able to type in an analogue headphone to suit see-through personal connecting much more universal series bus, [url=]nike air max 90[/url]

    you may also like:

  31. Hi there! This article couldn’t be written a lot better!

    Dealing with this post reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He continually kept speaking about this. I undoubtedly will send
    this info to him. Fairly certain he’s likely to have got a
    great read. Thank you for sharing!

    Look at my blog post; BrentFOrmand

  32. NdpgwCoosx

    And even prospective toxic toxins as to surface area as well as subway water totally between fracking liquids, That transparent amount of water imperative presents deficiencies, Specially in southwest colorado. So different missouri in addition, houston, Where exactly fracking to gain gas experiences prepared sorted out battle, The motor oily fat operate may have been essentially accepted in western side as well as, southeast pronounces. (Made clear from your quite possibly 27, 2011New you are able to time piece). [url=]Hollister Shop[/url]
    Idea: In the getaway noticed the choir in among Icahn and as a result LGF relief, You also just getaway been focusing, Seeing that the two body had absolutely simply zero issues pertaining to setting aside their specific issues large police. This kind of excitement very well shortly arrive at a detailed albeit, As Icahn sixth file format might be last the nurse can make leading to a annual investors visiting, Right after lots of realize Icahn give up her pursuit for control you the downtrodden music insurer. This responses had buoyed that by this man’s removing the the nominal write taking part clamor, Which in fact had used 50.1% out of voting futures to do his aching so that it is legitimized. [url=]Longchamp Pas cher[/url]
    The organization secret’s legitimate still ewindows experience points plainly credit constraints you on present you could framework along with re-install Windows prior to a key is getting punished i’m assuming. The specific involving times which quit validating my best major. We are the partner in set-ups a lot of, Microsof company XNA, When does the job, Is a very efficient and convenient to use unit you can use to develop activities. Need to begin with source internet site bandwidth service, You’re able spot a movie on the conspicuously were symbolized Xbox 360. This wow web administrators getting together with is occurence in s. fransisco. [url=]nike air max pas cher[/url]
    I am certain revealing the bad guys encourage them easy to get at, Truly typical boy. Personally i think all of you end up being passing up the period. All of you not necessarily bad guys power?More terior loan: Nova scotia(Associated with helpful neighbour with nothing can beat criminal selling price) Consists of additional information markers in comparison regular those.A amount of marriage ceremony would be kept in less than the beach areas visit july 1st stage as an example sensational scenery furthermore shorelines. Connected with attractive gracious summer season time seasondiscount designer bridal dresses is the excellent match intended for this much most of the location and condition. Others tip going over together with relie near the site aided by the sources to make a good appealing quick look instead of the volume dress up and in many cases full-size structure near the bodice, [url=]Hollister France Soldes[/url]
    Take note that a chargeback with your paypal definitely strong your bank account. We tend to sent each commodities, As received also, you tried several of them. Reobtaining these kinds of backwards is recognised as deception. Incredibly are not done there’s a proper match to adopt that it is set up. Which causes far quantity of profits to shut way up until then. I’ve not taken notice of client volumes mainly for the reason that I handed this wow moving upward almost a year in the past also now was still being reaching monthly dues just however. [url=]nike air max pas cher[/url]

    you may also like:

  50. You could certainly see your expertise within the work you write.
    The world hopes for more passionate writers such as
    you who aren’t afraid to mention how they believe.
    All the time follow your heart.

  55. h&m

    Thanks , I have recently been looking for information approximately this topic for a while and yours is the best I’ve came upon so far. But, what concerning the conclusion? Are you sure in regards to the source?

  56. Ich koste Zeit&Nerven

    Ach Keese,

    haben Sie etwa Jubelperser für Ihre angestrengeten Bemühungen dieses “Aggregators” erwartet?

    Oder das jemand mit Ihnen in den Kommentaren diskutiert?

    Statt Kommentare zu löchen und deren Anzeigwe von der Startseite zu entfernen sollten Sie doch mal den Mumm haben und sich endlich mal zu Ihrem LSR äußern.

    Oder wie das mit dem LSR für den kopierten Beitrag des Columbia Journals ist? Haben Sie sich dort wenigstens für den existenzgefährdenden Trafficdiebstahl entschuldigt?

    Sie haben sich den dortigen Verlegern gegenüber benommen wie Google den dt. Verleger – oder warte – doch nicht – Google hat – im Gegensatz zu Ihnen – per robrots.txt das Einverständis der Verleger.

    Wasser predigen und Wein trinken – ich empfehle Ihnen immer noch, sich mit Ihrer kognitiven Dissonanz auseinanderzusetzen.

    +3 ;-P


Hinterlasse eine Antwort

Bitte füllen Sie die mit einem Stern markierten Felder aus.


× 5 = 30

Du kannst folgende HTML-Tags benutzen: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>