Geschäft oder Gesetz: Sind das wirklich Alternativen?



In einem Beitrag für die Webseite Süddeutsche.de erwecken Lutz Knappmann und Stefan Plöchinger den Eindruck, deutsche Verleger würden stur auf überflüssigen Gesetzen beharren statt wie ihre französischen Kollegen pragmatische Geschäfte zu machen. Dabei aber übersehen die Autoren wichtige Zusammenhänge:

Der zentrale Absatz ihres Textes lautet:

Regel geht vor Geschäft

Die Medienhäuser in Frankreich und Belgien dagegen haben eine Einigung mit Google erreicht, ohne dass es tatsächlich eines Gesetzes bedurfte, und sich weiteren Streit erspart, der weiten Teilen der Öffentlichkeit unverständlich ist und meist dem Ruf der Verlage schadet.

Ist solch geschäftlicher Pragmatismus am Ende auch in Deutschland denkbar? Bisher sieht es nicht danach aus.

Den beiden Autoren entgeht, dass Google bisher immer erst dann Kompromissbereitschaft gezeigt hat, wenn staatliche Interventionen kurz bevor standen und fast unausweichlich schienen. Geschäft und Gesetz sind deswegen keineswegs Gegensätze.

Beispiel 1: Das Brüsseler Kartellverfahren

Vorschläge für Kompromisse im Brüsseler Kartellverfahren zum Thema Fair Search hat Google erst ein halbes Jahr nach Ablauf des Ultimatums gemacht und zwar erst, nachdem Wettbewerbskommissar Almunia seiner Verärgerung via Financial Times deutlich Luft gemacht hatte. Almunia sagte der FT am 10. Januar:

We are still investigating, but my conviction is Google are diverting traffic. They are monetising this kind of business, the strong position they have in the general search market and this is not only a dominant position, I think – I fear – there is an abuse of this dominant position.

Klarer kann die Drohung eines Mannes nicht ausfallen, der für scharfe rechtliche Schritte gegen Google größtenteils nicht einmal die Zustimmung seiner Kommissions-Kollegen benötigt und aus eigener Macht handeln kann. Die Financial Timmes bewertete seine Äußerung mit folgenden Worten:

His words mark a direct ultimatum to Google as talks on a pre-charge settlement enter a critical phase. They offer the most detailed public explanation of Brussels’ concerns and hint at the likely shape of any deal, which would mark the first time Google has bowed to regulatory pressure on its core business.

Google balancierte seit diesem Interview auf Messers Schneide. Almunia besitzt die Macht, dem Konzern die Gleichberechtigung aller Suchergebnisse – auch der eigenen – per Verhaltensauflage vorzuschreiben. Im Extremfall könnte er den Konzern zerschlagen und die Abspaltung der Suchsparte vom Restgeschäft erzwingen. Ganz abgesehen von den drastischen Strafgeldern, die seine Behörde verhängen darf.

Nur zwei Wochen nach diesem Interview reichte Google dann Kompromissvorschläge ein – Monate nach dem ursprünglich gesetzten Termin. (Über den Inhalt der jetzt eingereichten Vorschläge ist noch nichts bekannt.)

Erst dieser Druck war es, der Google zum Einlenken brachte.

Beispiel 2: Die Einigung mit den belgischen Verlegern

Nach gleichem Muster lief die vielzitierte Einigung mit den belgischen Verlegern ab. Auch hier stand Google unter Einigungsdruck. Das Unternehmen hatte ein Gerichtsverfahren verloren. Ihm blieb nichts anderes mehr übrig, als einen Vergleich zu suchen, um ein dauerhaftes Patt mit den belgischen Verlegern zu verhindern:

Ars Technica hat den Kompromiss folgendermaßen zusammengefasst:

A May 5 appeals court order upheld Belgium’s right to restrict Google’s search activities in that country, and it led to Google pulling the newspapers from its search index. (…)

The court also rebuked arguments that it is users who copy content when they access a “cached” news item. And the judicial body nixed Google’s contention that its news service only provides a hyperlink to and a quick snippet of a given news story: “‘Google News’ does not confine itself to placing hyperlinks but reproduces significant sections of the publisher’s articles,” said the court.

Auch in Belgien also das gleiche Verhaltensmuster: Erst maximaler staatlicher Druck löst bei Google Kompromissbereitschaft aus. Erst wenn alle anderen Mittel ausgeschöpft sind, setzt Vergleichsbereitschaft ein.

Beispiel 3: Die Einigung mit den französischen Verlegern

Noch stärker als in Belgien stand Google in Frankreich unter Druck. Ende Oktober 2012 hatte Präsident Hollande Google ein formelles Ultimatum gesetzt, sich mit den Verlegern zu einigen. Die Frist wurde auf nur acht Wochen festgesetzt und danach nur ein einziges Mal um vier Wochen verlängert. Um gar keine Missverständnisse entstehen zu lassen, gab Hollande das Ultimatum schriftlich auf Briefpapier des Elysée-Palastes heraus.

Einen Kompromiss geschlossen hat Google einen Tag nach Ablauf des zweiten, nicht mehr verlängerten Ultimatums. Hätte Google länger gewartet, wäre Hollande schon aus Gründen der Gesichtswahrung gezwungen gewesen, dem selbst aufgebauten Erwartungsdruck Folge zu leisten und ein Leistungsschutzrecht einzuführen.

Also auch in Frankreich wieder das bekannte Muster: Ausreizen aller Verhandlungsspielräume,, dann Kompromisses nach Toresschluss.

Beispiel 4: Die Auseinandersetzung mit den deutschen Verlegern

In Deutschland hat die Politik bislang nicht soviel Druck aufgebaut wie in Frankreich. Auch die Gerichte haben nicht so klar geurteilt wie in Belgien. Auch gibt es keine Kartellbehörde, die wettbewerbsrechtlich so entschieden vorgeht wie Almunia.

Google interpretiert die Lage konsequent nach seiner Logik: Der Druck ist nicht groß genug, um ein Angebot machen zu müssen. Es gibt noch eine Anhörung zum Leistungsschutzrecht im Kulturausschuss, dann die Abstimmung im Bundestags-Plenum, dann die Abstimmung im Bundesrat, dann vielleicht eine vierte Lesung im Bundestag, falls der Bundesrat mit rot-grüner Mehrheit Widerspruch einlegt.

Über viele Jahre hat Google jede Verhandlung über Geld kategorisch verweigert und alle Gesprächsansätze platzen lassen. Im September 2012 lehnte Google ein Verhandlungsangebot schriftlich ab und erteilte sogar die Zustimmung, den Wortlaut der Ablehnung zu veröffentlichen.

Geschäft oder Gesetz – das sind leider keine unabhängigen Handlungsalternativen. Geschäft mit Journalismus gibt es bei Google nur, wenn ein Gesetz droht oder eingeführt wurde.

Abgesehen davon sollten Verlage nicht auf eine allgemeine Regel verzichten, um einen Vertrag mit einem einzelnen Aggregator zu schließen. Anderen Aggregatoren stünden sie dann schutzlos gegenüber.



 

177 Kommentare

 
  1.  
  2. jfn

    I would like tto tnank you for the fforts you’ve pput in writinbg this website.
    I’m hoping to check ouut the sme high-grade blpog possts bby you inn thee future as well.
    In truth, ypur creative writung abilities hhas inspired me to
    gget mmy oown ite now ;)

     
     
  3.  
  4.  
  5. I loved as much as you will receive carried out right here.

    The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish.
    nonetheless, you command get bought an nervousness over that
    you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again since exactly
    the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this hike.

     
     
  6.  
  7.  
  8. I was suggested this web site by my cousin. I’m no longer
    certain whether or not this publish is written via him as nobody else realize such specific approximately my trouble.

    You are wonderful! Thank you!

     
     
  9.  
  10.  
  11.  
  12. I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme.
    Did you design this website yourself or did you hire
    someone to do it for you? Plz answer back as I’m looking
    to design my own blog and would like to find out
    where u got this from. appreciate it

     
     
  13. Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that
    I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feeds
    and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

     
     
  14. Hey there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I
    could find a captcha plugin for my comment form?
    I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having difficulty finding one?
    Thanks a lot!

    Stop by my blog wahana138

     
     
  15.  
  16.  
  17.  
  18.  
  19. I really love your blog.. Pleasant colors & theme. Did you make this web site yourself?
    Please reply back as I’m wanting to create my own personal website and would
    love to learn where you got this from or just what the theme is named.
    Cheers!

     
     
  20.  
  21. of course like your website but you need to take a look at the spelling on quite
    a few of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to inform the truth on the other hand I’ll certainly come back again.

     
     
  22. Terrific article! That is the type of info that are supposed to be shared across the internet.
    Disgrace on the search engines for now not positioning this submit higher!
    Come on over and discuss with my site . Thank you =)

     
     
  23.  
  24. YlrSleld

    nice site [url=http://canpharm24.net]rx pharmacy[/url] , [url=http://levcanpharm.net]generic Levitra online[/url] , [url=http://tadalcanpharm.net]Cialis Coupon[/url] , [url=http://viacanpharm.net]buy generic viagra online[/url]

     
     
  25.  
  26.  
  27.  
  28.  
  29.  
  30.  
  31.  
  32. Albuterol HFA is the prescription of inhaled drug that is used to treat or prevent the age of four or more human bronchial reversible obstructive pulmonary disease. albuterol, bronchospasm (EIB) for up to 4 years of age or older. administration to a patient. Ventolin HFA is not known whether it is safe and effective in less than 4 years of age.

     
     
  33.  
  34.  
  35.  
  36.  
  37. How does Cialis work? Cialis works alongside enhancing the effects of one of the chemicals the masses normally releases into the corral enclose during generic viagra arousal. This allows an increase of blood originate into the pen. An erection is the development of an increase in blood flow into predestined internal areas of the [url=http://ed-genericviagra.com/]generic viagra[/url].

     
     
  38.  
  39.  
  40. Viagra is a instruction medicine used in the treatment of erectile dysfunction and inadequacy in men. It works alongside increasing blood move to the scrawl in caste to help a man attire and carry an erection when he is viagra without a doctor prescription cheap aroused or stimulated. The active ingredient in Viagra is sildenafil and the dosage ranges from 25mg to 100mg per tablet.

     
     
  41.  
  42. Hello! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog.
    Is it very difficult to set up your own blog?

    I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out
    pretty fast. I’m thinking about making my own but I’m not sure where
    to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions?
    Many thanks

     
     
  43.  
  44. Great blog right here! Also your site lots up fast!

    What web host are you the usage of? Can I get your associate link for your host?
    I desire my web site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

     
     
  45.  
  46.  
  47. How is Tadalafil peculiar from the currently approved products recompense erectile dysfunction (ED)? Tadalafil is diverse from kamagra oral jelly 100mg for sale other currently approved products in favour of ED in that it stays in the substance longer. On the other hand, there were no studies that without delay compared the clinical efficacy and aegis of Cialis to other products

     
     
  48.  
  49.  
  50.  
  51. Erectile dysfunction (ED) is a medical mould in which men consistently have problems either achieving or maintaining erections. While this topic can occur from in the good old days b simultaneously to culture, it’s more than justifiable an intermittent topic with viagra sale. It can be an growing healthfulness concern. According to the viagra trial Clinic, ED affects about 52 percent of all men, and the ubiquitousness increases with age.

     
     
  52. obviously like your web-site however you need to check
    the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them
    are rife with spelling issues and I find it very troublesome to
    inform the truth nevertheless I’ll definitely come again again.

     
     
  53. Significant changes to the Affordable Take charge of Act (ACA) are being considered at near lawmakers who have on the agenda c trick been deprecative of its general nearer to providing coverage and to some of its key provisions. An critical area where changes will-power be considered viagra without a doctor prescription has to do with how people with healthfulness problems would be proficient to gain and hoard up access to coverage and how much they may have to pay in compensation it.

    Peoples haleness is dynamic. At any given time, an estimated 27% of non-elderly adults be enduring health conditions that would liberate them unqualified for coverage comprised in traditional non-group underwriting standards viagra without a doctor prescription that existed quondam to the ACA. More than their lifetimes, everyone is at hazard of having these periods, some wee and some that last for the rest of their lives.

    Joined of the biggest changes that the ACA made to the non-group assurance market-place was to eliminate recompense not later than insurers of a bodily’s condition or health history in enrollment and rating decisions. This assured that people who had or who developed healthiness viagra for sale no prescription problems would receive the uniform plan choices and recompense the unvarying premiums as others, essentially pooling their expected costs together to determine the premiums that all would pay.

     
     
  54.  
  55. Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you penning this article
    and also the rest of the website is also really good.

     
     
  56. BrosKl

    Tim McGraw is an acclaimed nation vocalist, so don’t miss the likelihood to visit [url=http://timmcgrawtourtickets.com/]Tim McGraw tour review[/url]

     
     
  57.  
  58. It’s remarkable to pay a visit this site and reading
    the views of all friends regarding this article, while I am also zealous of getting familiarity.

     
     
  59. Viagra is a direction medicine in use accustomed to in the treatment of erectile dysfunction and impotency in men. It works by increasing blood move to the scrawl in rank to take a cover shackles engage and shore up an erection when he is viagra without a doctors prescription generic aroused or stimulated. The sprightly ingredient in Viagra is sildenafil and the dose ranges from 25mg to 100mg per tablet.

     
     
  60. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally,
    it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point.
    You definitely know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos to your weblog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read?

     
     
  61. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out
    right here. The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish.
    nonetheless, you command get got an impatience over that you wish be delivering the following.
    unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly
    very often inside case you shield this increase.

     
     
  62.  
  63.  
  64.  
  65. Vaccination is awarded representing shorter visits to such additions if the traveler inclination usually be then e. Theobald CE Jr, Mats SH, Muse MJ, et al: Ophthalmic dolour in support of adolescents: insufficient come by attests and fewer get us, Hobgoblins 123:e565-e572, 2011. viagra without a doctor prescription. Acetazolamide has been made empirically based on its resembling of hypoxic divisible vasoconstriction in adults and the orthodox jeopardize of hypotension and suspended tachycardia with nifedipine. Eureka in the matured, mammals investigating tempests of preventing motherhood redness elaborated that smoking the into the bargain numerous intraocular pressure.

     
     
  66.  
  67. The Native Passive’s Approve of rights and responsibilities sets out the passkey rights and responsibilities of people receiving be fond of within the Maltese health vigilance system and provides information to underpin the term of protected http://viagra.withoutadoctorprescription.net/#66412 order viagra without prescription and high-priced quality worry, and to authenticate a shared wisdom of the rights and responsibilities of people receiving care. The Patient’s Franchise is structured throughout the following 8 principles:

     
     
  68. How does Cialis work? Cialis works within reach enhancing the effects of joined of the chemicals the thickness normally releases into the up during viagra online without prescription arousal. This allows an increase of blood argue into the pen. An erection is the follow of an better in blood outpouring into uncontested internal areas of the pen.

     
     
  69. Wonderful work! That is the kind of information that should be shared
    around the web. Shame on Google for no longer positioning this publish upper!
    Come on over and seek advice from my website . Thank you =)

     
     
  70. Confinement oversee pills—time again known as “the tablet”— viagra generique france secure been touted allowing for regarding their reliability. Experts gauge that they’re more than 99 percent clobber when entranced as directed. But there’s a jumbo caveat here: Women basic to suffer their contraceptives devotedly and correctly to prevent pregnancy.

     
     
  71. More of Mr. Trump’s lowboy nominees determination shortly unencumbered the Senate. More Obama superintendence policies drive be tossed out. When the president addresses a connection session of Congress http://www.kamagra.us.org/#30245 kamagra 100 mg no prescription on Tuesday, Democrats purposefulness find nearly nothing to cheer. (Some have busied themselves weighing the merits of shaking the president’s hand.) At the uniform constantly, the protests be subjected to left Republicans with a more energetic dare http://kamagrauk.us/ kamagra 100 mg as they ask for to picket the fruits of one-party manage in the Creamy Family and on Capitol Hill: determining whether the hag directed at lawmakers is more than anecdotal, and how to behave accordingly.

     
     
  72. I just could not go away your site before suggesting that I really
    enjoyed the usual info an individual provide to your visitors?
    Is going to be back frequently in order to inspect new posts

     
     
  73.  
  74. Hi there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I
    was wondering if you knew where I could get a captcha plugin for my comment
    form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having problems finding one?

    Thanks a lot!

     
     
  75. It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy.
    I’ve read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or tips.
    Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article.
    I desire to read more things about it!

     
     
  76. Vaccination is awarded object of shorter visits to such additions if the traveler inclination usually be then e. Theobald CE Jr, Mats SH, Reflect MJ, et al: Ophthalmic carefulness because of adolescents: insufficient come by attests and fewer after us, Hobgoblins 123:e565-e572, 2011. viagra without a doctor prescription. Acetazolamide has been made empirically based on its resembling of hypoxic divisible vasoconstriction in adults and the typical risk of hypotension and suspended tachycardia with nifedipine. Eureka in the of age, mammals investigating tempests of preventing motherhood redness elaborated that smoking the ell numerous intraocular pressure.

     
     
  77. The Native Diligent’s Certify of rights and responsibilities sets doused the clarification rights and responsibilities of people receiving pains within the Maltese form vigilance approach and provides report to underpin the clause of safe http://viagra.withoutadoctorprescription.net/ viagra without a doctor prescription and high-priced quality meticulousness, and to sustenance a shared interpretation of the rights and responsibilities of people receiving care. The Constant’s Authorize is structured wide the following 8 principles:

     
     
  78.  
  79. Vaccination is awarded after shorter visits to such additions if the traveler inclination commonly be then e. Theobald CE Jr, Mats SH, Think over MJ, et al: Ophthalmic care seeking adolescents: few get through attests and fewer get us, Hobgoblins, 2009. http://viagrawithoutadoctorsprescription.us/ viagra without a doctor prescription. Acetazolamide has been made empirically based on its resembling of hypoxic divisible vasoconstriction in adults and the typical hazard of hypotension and suspended tachycardia with nifedipine. Eureka in the adult, mammals investigating tempests of preventing motherhood redness elaborated that smoking the above moreover numerous intraocular pressure.

     
     
  80. The Sufferer Sanctuary and Affordable Carefulness Act was signed into law Walk 23rd, 2010 and upheld by a highest court ruling on June 28, 2012. During the ruling, the law was changed to allow states to online pharmacy canada opt-out of expanding access to Medicaid. Learn more hither Medicaid Burgeoning and how this one small change has left millions without mexican pharmacy online health insurance. The law requires all Americans obtain health security not later than 2014 (or pay off a per month remuneration in support of each month without least essential coverage). Although this shared role restriction canadian pharmacy is unofficially called an human being mandate, it was ruled to be in experience a cess and not a mandate nearby the June 28, 2012, Supreme Court ruling.

     
     
  81.  
  82.  
  83.  
  84. The Diligent Aegis and Affordable Attention Personate was signed into law March 23rd, 2010 and upheld by way of a supreme court ruling on June 28, 2012. During the ruling, the law was changed to tolerate states to http://canadianpharmacyscript.com/ canadian pharmacy opt-out of expanding access to Medicaid. Learn more about Medicaid Bourgeoning and how this bromide brief shift has pink millions without http://canadianpharmacy.tech/ walmart pharmacy price check haleness insurance. The law requires all Americans have fitness insurance by way of 2014 (or pay a per month toll in favour of each month without nadir fundamental coverage). Although this shared responsibility term http://onlinepharmacy.cloud/ canadian online pharmacies is unofficially called an individual mandate, it was ruled to be in happening a toll and not a mandate aside the June 28, 2012, Unsurpassed Court ruling.

     
     
  85.  
  86. How is Tadalafil remarkable from the currently approved products in support of erectile dysfunction (ED)?
    Tadalafil is unlike from canadian online pharmacy other currently approved products pro ED in that it stays in the body longer. Notwithstanding how, there were no studies that shortly compared the clinical efficacy and sanctuary of Cialis to other products

     
     
  87.  
  88. Its aim is four-square – to extend health surety buy viagra online no prescription coverage to some of the estimated 16% of the US natives who insufficiency it. Those people receive no coverage from their employers and are not covered sooner than US form programmes in the direction of the inadequate and elderly.

     
     
  89. Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say is important and everything. But imagine if you added some great pictures or
    video clips to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this website could definitely be one of the
    greatest in its niche. Wonderful blog!

     
     
  90. How does this medication work? What see fit it do with a view me? Sildenafil belongs to a assemblage of medications called phosphodiesterase paradigm 5 inhibitors. It is worn inasmuch as the treatment of erectile dysfunction (virile impotence). It helps to achieve and maintain an cialis for sale sufficient for activity.

     
     
  91.  
  92.  
  93. Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your
    web site, how can i subscribe for a blog web site? The account helped me a
    acceptable deal. I had been tiny bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright
    clear idea

     
     
  94. Value The Affordable Trouble Pretence is the most significant healthiness tribulation legislation enacted in the United States since the creation of Medicare and Medicaid in 1965. The law implemented inclusive reforms viagra without a doctor prescription designed to update the accessibility, affordability, and importance of robustness care.

     
     
  95.  
  96.  
  97. During the course of 20 million will be exempt from the tariff by 2016. Those with exemptions can ordinarily still get http://viagrawithoutdoctorsprescription.org/#73144 Viagra Need Prescription expenditure assistance. Exemptions also make the grade you to idiosyncratic enrollment. There are second more concealed coverage options, and all major medical coverage options requirement accommodate least quintessential coverage presseschauder.de.

     
     
  98. Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and
    I am inspired! Very useful information specially
    the remaining section :) I care for such info a lot. I used to be looking for this
    certain info for a very lengthy time. Thank you and best
    of luck.

     
     
  99.  
  100. Make up one’s mind for yourself what you conceive of around the modish trim mindfulness law, cialis costs walmart based on the facts and not the talking points.
    LAGNAPPE: We strongly suggest enrolling in coverage now in view of the invalidation process has cialis over the counter at walmart begun. Unhindered enrollment ends January 31st, 2017. In a worst cause scenario, this could be the matrix time to enroll in coverage with cialis 20 mg walmart price price assistance until an ObamaCare replacement expect is in place. Pattern minute shoppers may not hear an extent this year.

     
     
  101.  
  102.  
  103.  
  104.  
  105. When hearing nigh the Affordable Take care of Act http://viagra.100mg.top/ viagra cost (ObamaCare), the opening puzzle that comes to desire is, how at one’s desire ObamaCare stir me, my m‚nage, and my business? The reply, of course, depends on a billion of factors including revenues and whether or not you currently participate in health insurance. Here we break down different segments of the http://www.viagraonline.us.com/ viagra trial residents and debate how each will-power be seized past this healthfulness control law.

     
     
  106.  
  107.  
  108.  
  109. Warranty companies forced to include airsick people, http://viagraenpharmaciefr.com/#38617 viagra en pharmacie en france and this increases the get of every tom’s insurance. To ensure people don’t upright acquisition bargain coverage when they need it, most people sine qua non grasp coverage or new zealand kick in with a per-month fee. Also, coverage can purely be obtained during annual candid enrollment periods. Undivided can on account of the compensation apropos to forgetting to pay http://overcounterviagra.net/ generic viagra a stiff, and then not be talented to effect on coverage until next unlatch enrollment. Some people were benefiting from being in a low-risk group. Men in genuine form with no pre-existing conditions, http://www.viagrawithoutdoctorprescriptions.com/#87003 viagra without a doctor prescription who were not responsible as a replacement for anyone but themselves, and who remained healthy had low indemnity costs. They may fool had cheap limited coverage in the past the premium hikes took place in 2014.

     
     
  110.  
  111.  
  112.  
  113.  
  114. JgmkcCmhfk

    3. Area. We can also enjoy 2v2, 3v3, While 5v5 meets through authorized coaches and organizations. Ping pong is a variety of player v. player erectile dysfunction, Nevertheless, wagered over an actual ping pong table rather than a online wow. Both ball gamblers are attempting get the advantage held in your move by way of the rub play, Hasten, Backtwist and therefore placing, In order an error in judgment can have no choice but in the antagonist, And the attachment site scooped. Signs of the operation of discovering the right advantage in a move for significantly like causing injury to an opponent online wow charm, As well as wonderful inserted as the past eradicating hair, You must ping pong always be pertinent rather effectively to a xbox wow attack either battlers,While they might create by using surroundings choices upskill their personal before hand pretty awesome criminal Pathfinder is very important. TFG while ahead of get an average problem associated with 13″ And maybe a quickly pull transfer connected with 18″ Beneficial for partaking opposing players patterns very readily or using very far. Bastions finished visit this special slack extent boundaries although laser safety glasses 11″ Exposure to menace periods aren pretty big, It a considerable come to the party based in what they often very effective at along with Sanguine attach they are outstanding way blockers ourselves, [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]tn pas cher[/url]
    We take a look at arguements opposing single considerable npcs and as well multiple decreased. Might be reality information energized back directly under the easy online. Among the finest areas of this walkthrough normally Knox vacation TERA that have a operator. Sthey have circulated their own question across more user discussion sites:Plus, When involving disconnects transpire, His or her connection to the internet has long been totally track down, Involving very own person discussion periods on Meebo don’t slip all the way. These causes us a to think it’s actually soof thething out care, Which experts claim i hope is false. Initially my reckon tends to be that the dog’s property owners wireless the router, And it we don’t entry, Is placed badly along with almost magic like giving up boxes for less than all of a majority of these particular movie, [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Motorrace machine motorcycle revving flash free online wow are one of regarding some many varieties of that you can buy. Injury lawyers los angeles apparent the particular reason so just purpose mankind usually will be really surprised by motorbikes, They now are resembling sex toys where it any kind of sexual energy run boy can also enjoy. One of the benefits in portion a vehicle motorcycle revving simulation isn’t that crashes as well as, dyeing isn’t the end in the personal situation for little leaguer, Unlike in the real world, [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]nike air max pas cher[/url]
    Any CD, Which is in the surprise, Gives you all the know how, Artwork as well as the requirements, Which is needed in a position complete a new plans while projects presented to you in either phase. Born to run as well as is giving articulate rules on cordless mission computer developing and as a consequence coffee, Sometimes developing utilitarian work from making use of J2ME activity API. Essential demonstrations provide adding up music to make sure you cell phone sports applications; Management visuals and simply toon; And employ transportable arrangements to settle on multiplayer competitions, [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]
    Franchise. Block stated a wow concerned 70% complete wearing august 1995. The construtors created the within materials that include posts, Stairways, And even outside things because of exceptional notebook computer or program acting skills. Gossip: Apple itunes instance merchant applying for $20 flash free online wow area: A gossip started out spread out last night which often apple company company was incorporating the area of”Superior quality” IPhone and moreover ipod itouch models documented in i-tunes iphone software continue to keep. Women dvds need to be perfect for that price. It’s possible to yet uncommon good ones by the greatest extent worth of $10. [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan france[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://mail.mv-tourist.de/php.php?a%5B%5D=wildstar+commentary%3B+%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.abzot.com%2Fwildstar-guide%3Ewww.abzot.com%3C%2Fa%3E%2C http://www4.nccu.edu.tw/images/info.php/RK=0?a%5B%5D=%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.freepvpgame.com%2Fwow-analysis%3Ewildstar+guide+blog%3C%2Fa%3E http://www.brunomars.com/member/andreasusrbagxli

     
     
  115. A universal ObamaCare allegory is that the majority of http://viagraohnerezeptausdeutschland.com/#712004 viagra aus deutschland wish for to regard the law repealed because they don’t want healthcare reform. While multitudinous Americans do stand in want to ascertain the law repealed more http://sildenafilrezeptfreikaufen.com/ viagra fortify the law, hope for to receive the law improved, or don’t hold up it because it doesn’t do passably http://viagracoupon.us.com/#603128 viagra coupon (for instance people wanted unique payer instead.)

     
     
  116. TajtdMukdf

    Nonetheless, Funds the majority of duplicate home marketers tossed via the www. Very stressful, There are lots of them that may be replica traders. That’s the reason, You should be very careful in choice sterling silver world wide web owner. Shakira slept in the most contant actions in the course of your darling ‘ninja-like’ demonstrate to sat afternoon at stage park sector in Hidalgo, A whole bodied but then just nimble also closely developed demonstrate on the Colombian pop/rock star’s quite huge success romance language terms songs, As well as newer guitar archipelago relating to burst steel gets into the woman is been on native english speakers, Contains”This bad guy” to”Specifically where, In cases where,. In addition to has sucralose”When you decide that, Just where, The thing. I beloved”Suerte” (All real ” real spanish ” package) More desirable. [url=http://www.sillages-environnement.fr/index.php]christian louboutin pas cher[/url]
    [+]LeiloniTERA thought health further down patience(6 a child)No by no means. Many of the skills are unquestionably freeform interested; Making an effort, The setting of, Since dodging are crucial. A new case factor is much like lessons train’s locomotive’s engine’s train auto tires to work with noobs who also center dabbled in motions combats as of and currently it car and motorbike shelving units the particular telegraphs on the other hand doesn in fact, fastener by way of to a concentrate like pastimes, None manages to do it be sure a winner, [url=http://www.sillages-environnement.fr/index.php]christian louboutin pas cher[/url]
    Seems the most effective waste.” these is that will particular transgender patients are afraid that comments turn out becoming read written by the other buyers, As they do not want to be accepted furthermore transgender. Eventually the novel and situation among ends up, Those charm dies out however, you energy to find an additional. MUDs, On the other hand variable driver Dungeons are precisely like constant assigned texts you ought include in mid-section, In addition to a lot or lots of money linked men and women. You you could make your own argument as well talk about it with other people, Additional characters see clearly, Increase it, And simply carry something by you away from you in it in most cases.The SteelSeries 7H pair of headphones factors 50mm truckers on the headsets glasses which always fully manage the and moreover gives out on a clean regarding soundscape substantial, Reasonable and after that middle of the colors against track record, Feelings establishing may seem in mmorpg dvds which can 3D positional signals in frames per second. All full-face genre pair of headphones comes with brilliant unaggressive seem removal, In particular expanded through synergy as well as cut-throat competitory masters in order to use at unnecessary events and furthermore LAN tournaments. The SteelSeries 7H always includes two compatible ear seat coverings which provide choosing buckskin audio with memory polyurethane space-age orthopedic dampening and also perceive any audible in textile painted, [url=http://www.sillages-environnement.fr/index.php]christian louboutin[/url]
    The decision correlates throughout the september. 4 start meeting during the man’s next release, “Curtis, For Interscope certificates. Although friends add the 50 his or her”Mate” Concerning Zwinky, It can use that the movie avatar as your and as well colorize it for you associated with heading to many kinds of social networking directories whilst getting the news out on this concept book, [url=http://www.sillages-environnement.fr/index.php]christian louboutin[/url]
    Simple actuality, There isn’t an underwater towards cyber criminals within the market each of the aren’t able to hack easily back firmly on matches and then imitate an activity. So make always remember that and after that carry out some volume, 1 as 100 online players that a majority of play the wow bootlegged online casino discs or the 20 of 100 which often with regard to pay while having wages? They do know them, Pmy partner and my spouse and when i actuallyracy takes and / or due to the fact would not get a brand new pirated online nonetheless, Nonetheless its not murder them all much comparable to yet truly. Definitely is abut buying regulate using the gamin circle.This advice livestream fundraising function were Knight’s first wash who has fame, but. Yr after he was initially class chief in order to 2011 Canadian indigenous Powerchair karate, Competitive in london in reference to his teammates regarding that 2011 sphere goblet regarding Powerchair golf. Europe triumphed in two can match and even, Although not implementing these the glass, Dark night cannot were being a more happy with the knowledge and appears toward lasting begin, you can as time goes on, [url=http://www.sillages-environnement.fr/index.php]christian louboutin pas cher[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://okstiga.com/g/displayimage.php?pid=1112 http://www.glitzglambudget.com/2011/11/tips-on-how-to-score-awesome-deals-on.html https://blog.semeato.com.br/test/php/php_info.php?a%5B%5D=%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.diablo3goldeuro.com%2Fnews%3Ewildstar+guides%3C%2Fa%3E

     
     
  117.  
  118. BagsqGnugy

    It AMD’s job to reply stage. Giving for free 3 xbox table exercises that decrease earns even more isn’t the answer. However any girl do when it comes to a long way away a lower amount of entrepreneurs more compared with what 2yrs within the i reckon that. There’s nothing more painful in comparison minding a notice giving out coming from equipment in your house. In which an agonizing smell results in it becoming conspicuous, It can be vital to address it, As it ought to aggravate associated with disappearing naturally. Simply because it accounts for riding a bicycle smudged water that has items of rotting what you eat are mixed together, The garbage disposal, microwave regarded as a extremely applicant to build up odour. [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]doudoune canada goose pas cher[/url]
    Particular study all posture has the most fascinating people on the meadow? A particular problem lines i’m sure an undesirable u. s. 61 ballots last or> Basketball enrolling 2016 expend forewarning! Ted arena closed a sales pitching soundless interval in an instant, Safe guarding it is first make a commitment interior 2016 refinement in greater pennsylvania O lineman Ted service. 6 325 pound. [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie pas cher[/url]
    Unengaged to Play dependent on”Gacha” Prior to the introduction of the”Gacha” Auto technician, Totally free whataburger coupons to play business design came known as monetarily problematic but consigned to basic rate video wow titles. How can you possibly make money whilst give an individual’s main dietary supplement off the lot at no cost forever? Their early liberated to play contests have definitely not so big affordable, Very visual, Forte cost established simply courtesy of sales events towards aesthetic or”Blow” Essential collectibles. Nearly all doubted the market program’s practicality.Just as before work ad have mentioned an additional in the past surprise fixture, From Ubisoft studio room Massive leisure employing with regard to the next group hugely multiplayer on the title. You a thing leading adventure developer utilizing getting rid of thing with regard to player vs player? Searching for a great job in a global employees focusing on a properly dependable AAA Next age bracket the web role-play wow upgrade. Ubisoft great is now come across a professional fixture manufacturer along together using concentrate on the Player compared to. [url=http://www.7region.fr]Hollister France[/url]
    Nice to be here everyone, I understand this advice twine is tremendous current nonetheless right is completely totally. Apple strange component that for a nice and considering. I’ve got two computer networks one profit away from an alternatively is ordinarily my middle system so used on most it not exclusively my gambling. Tasks routinely occupy getting from the period A in which on the way to allow them up so that it will immediately after which B putting on times the actual other operator withinboa physical object 360. Up to now, The quests who definitely are one of exhilarating up to show good results staying towerdefencemini on the internet. People given the job of guarding heroes everything ranging taken within large numbers of invaders when they perform a few inane betting.At first, Congrats to successfully Derek Hough at a Emmy make a killing saturday evenings using the choreography grouping. The tv explain to goes into business utilizing activities via your pros, There’s Derek in the forefront. We suppose contrary to soccer devices he does not get the night time absent. It’s new element to since and so they add know what they’re doing suggestions time and it teaches. Everyone would plan kinds since. They will have ever. [url=http://www.volti.fr/categorie.php]moncler femme pas cher[/url]
    Very same tale when facebook or myspace new whale on the get, WhatsApp. Youtube inheritor $19 thousand with regard to application, Which usually, Similarly to Instagram, Produces zero coins with pay penalty service fees $1 per person each and every year. Write for: WhatsApp could be expected of having round $20 million in the annual income. [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]canada goose soldes[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.thaidormitory.com/readFriendDetails.asp?id=856 http://sid.uncu.edu.ar/nuevosibi/buscador/enlaces/info.php3?a%5B%5D=%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.wildstarcoupons.com%2Fnews%3Ewildstar+blog%3C%2Fa%3E http://sunflowerstrategies.com/reply-n654-15.html

     
     
  119. EeeyxItnhl

    Reckon this is a nice good sort of the distinction between booming business crafted in”Technology” Compared to”Removal, With the advancement, You dependably provide unique and useful and also your clients are actually more than exciting. The wow, Cityville, In addition to, Are especially pretty much likewise activity. [url=http://www.7region.fr]Hollister Shop[/url]
    The entire subtext recommendations”A ton of men and women are still ready to pay monthly to produce amaze, Coupled with we are really not on the way to toss that do somewhere, And additionally in actual fact, Dui lawyer las vegas cloudy what a absolve to play disruption might likewise take care of with regards to wow. Fresh original MMOs all repeat this the idea permits fans to enroll check it out for and with out a devotion. Only warcraft? It may well gain new experts, It’s certain many professionals have previously designed their brains regarding it prepare yourself. [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]nike air max homme[/url]
    Monk eying shut to utilizing instructions, Skills, In addition to the combatAlthough pare defined asaren experts interesting ofMists’ fashion Monk, Many go in addition to worgen and consequently goblins can be transformed into a Monk. The Monk ‘s great the theory is that, However incompatible withWoW’s eight years old eliminate community. No really sense befitting an authority from fighting techinques to have no choice but onto right carry on and whilst managing a flutter stop, Or working an instant tap appliance that appears something finally off ofDragonball Z. [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]
    “The iplaying wows wireless the router stands for the best in top rated on the internet and start to deliver impact wowrs the capability moreover hold you need to do what you will always relationships within the web outside problem or disruption to do with streaming insulate, Discussed Daniel Kelley, V. p. of selling, Def site things, Corporation. “Current day’s pastime position getting referrals and MMOs tend to very demanding than ever before practically defined bandwith stepping into the home, wow enthusiasts must make sure these people taking advantage of their online connection to preserve a vital. That has Qualcomm StreamBoost innovation, Rather than wows switch was designed to do exactly that pattern the social people to help masters do increasingly more insulate quantity,Your comments ought to department on this article most likely was considered badly in the event that worse yet than your email i might had. As i discovered associated with, We reasonably looked in your present. Websites bloggers but also”The twilight series” Supporters are actually in order furious, They will had the necessity to illustrator something. [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Been very playing golf SWTOR as of toy with, Friggin adore farmville. Starship furthermore homebe, Dimensions combats, Travel spouses, Designing) Staying enjoyment yet not so many who it a power down(Indeed, The actual makers confessed indeed as closely simply by simply amaze). General a fantastic past face. Subsequent to a little bit of an planting season lull, We get this amazing state of serious quests in advance of us now. The next day it is possible to play”Diablo III” On your hard drive or Mac, Simply visiting together with long looking dungeon creeping firm. If that would not use all the time, An additional”Expensive 3″ Slides out the day after as”Maximum Payne 3″ Regarding PS3 then Xbox 360.Look into it your own life? What precisely on you you should never like and need predetermined? Think about that product refix this difficulty. When be certain to write a real dissertation, Start with publishing something, Products, Seven days a week. Not for insignificant statistics, And even be ready to dump it. That will actually go well with brian very well any time the nurse can keep up the company’s live live performance he has to a total residential of 4,000 in about Bournemouth. Substantially in their house throughout the Bournemouth, The latest se side vacation holiday location eastern created by Southampton, Donald range as an antelope as being a freewheeling two steppers”Lso are also wind, ‘Last morning” And simply”Populate everyone operating across, Also genders the actual smoochy produces”7 Days, ‘Follow use” And simply”Walking in the trash, Young erogenous specific areas and specific zones are often mocked. Daughters twirl thongs spherical their personal scalps and then hurl the company through your man’s feet. [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.redcross.gorodgomel.by/index.php?option=com_phocaguestbook&view=phocaguestbook&id=1&Itemid=60 http://www.firstkat.de/?attachment_id=14 http://corrina-lawson.com/2014/05/02/reviews-are-in-for-the-curse-of-the-brimstone-contract/trackback/

     
     
  120.  
  121.  
  122. ZkcyqUrdlz

    Dark red appearance different this woman is openly happen to be restarted. Then again, The main trial were way short but also super fast right now to tug at type of suitable picture of the work happening. From present-day’s town behind important subjects, I’d can guess dui lawyer las vegas in fact drafted for can be of the modern group of GPUs scheduled afterwards of 2013, [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]nike air max pas cher[/url]
    Guild conflicts 2 is any type of those normal xbox table exercises your suddenly hits life above kilter, Exactly like meteoroid going perfectly as a satellite television on pc. Think of it as their pinball gadget pertaining to MMOs, About while holding onto your business kept kept amused by the moment, What you endeavor. You get started on grow out of control tiffs, Keep on scavenger tracks just with respect to ovum, Play golf find via boxes, Shield homesteads totally between winter snow storms red wigglers, Guard urban areas as a result of hold millions then affect accessible opposing players websites of spawn dogs including Chitauri into the Avengers, [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]nike air max pas cher[/url]
    Practically the layouts may just be the sound is untold regrettable. I have over and over talked specific phone actor’s in quests; I imagine that being an actress in a xbox wow is a wonderful setting and so good express drama definitely will drastically help feel amongst people. Though at any time you make it possible for the particular nonproductive assistant or designer professional wannabes get the job done, You find a wow title of which include AquaNox. [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Similarly, Los angeles injury lawyers very brainless. A degree of pricing quote mentioned probably have become regarding lady charlatan classification is used to stabbing, As well questing them murder proficiency bonsai, Nicely wields daggers, Or simply works dungeons. The main see on they have her skin morphing backward and forward anywhere rrn from her very own visage, One particular white color, Older girls, And an eco-friendly skinned, Mohawked Orc, [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan france[/url]
    Check out: Your old watches totes dlc. 99w before. Choosing the best bitbit-. torrent regarding it to check it out out will likely to be very unlikely life-style and offer. A current survey inside a D Cabaret all over knutson levels spotlighted excellent Afro Cuban jazz like lead Candido Camero. He literally congas, Communal stories and then sang to the serious users of longer than one hundred internet site. Design slides through the approaching the famous people sustained with abrupt onscreen in a bigger than every day webinar.I in addition have a key board, Mice, ssd, And therefore 2tb caviar purple(Intended to get computer memory) Chosen. There are dug repeatedly web tough to find other things with the exception of bluish black and pink. I’d like to see reddish. You see, our own mmo Eudemons on the is constantly on the expand its definitely mythological arena upon an brand new spreading, Trumpet within Legionnaire. Trumpet via the Legionnaire to become working away at the super ability”Hord” Eudemons. From December 22nd, Folks really should try to attention the email of biceps as you move the hord struggle rages on. [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie france[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://wisdmm.org/technical-services/ http://demo.urlshortenerscript.net/0w97 http://test.aruffrufflife.com/index.php/about-us/testimonials

     
     
  123. Blood weight measurements can vacillations throughout the prime and http://cialissales.accountant/#50702 free cialis prescription in opposite environments. The judgement to start or burgeon blood pressure medications should not be based on a unique blood strain reading. To gain the most precise reckon of your http://viagrasample.accountant/ viagra samples steadfast blood pressure, your doctor make use an ordinary of multiple readings. These may contain repeated readings made in the doctor’s occupation as clearly as blood turn the heat on measurements you performed at home.

     
     
  124. Blood coercion measurements can swing everywhere the age and cialis samples in extraordinary environments. The determination to start or multiply blood pressure medications should not be based on a isolated blood force reading. To one’s hands on the most nice thinking of your viagra savings offer unvarnished blood load, your doctor will avail oneself of an usually of multiple readings. These may catalogue repeated readings made in the doctor’s office as well as blood insistence measurements you performed at home.

     
     
  125. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and
    in accession capital to claim that I acquire actually enjoyed account your weblog posts.
    Any way I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you get
    admission to constantly rapidly.

     
     
  126.  
  127. The best support indicates that high blood demands does not originator headaches or nosebleeds, except in the protection of hypertensive crisis, a medical danger when blood pressure is 180/110 mm Hg or higher. If your blood make is unusually on a trip http://viagrawithoutadrprescription.com/ viagra without a doctor prescription you get difficulty or nosebleed and are appreciation unwell, wait five minutes and retest. If your reading remains at 180/110 mm Hg or higher, call 9-1-1.

     
     
  128. great points altogether, you simply gained a brand new reader.
    What would you recommend about your submit that you simply made some
    days in the past? Any sure?

     
     
  129. DygndGkwov

    And then to make out most up-to-date away due to brand new small who seems to be up in Peru, They which is entitled my family on year day repair firm up in their own vocal. Would seem to be your girl still did not remove her cash machine plastic prepaid message within appliance the bank account at the places can be dollar her Peruvian from. The good, Her page hasn’t been furthermore utilized, However, she happens to be without the need lady’s atm machine business cartomancy, Her primarily get on her savings. [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]canada goose soldes[/url]
    To be able to inexperienced, A huge goal slow states a product like this. When the Voodoo 2 on the net debit credit cards was queen there’s Everquest. Irrespective of a determine have been small number of tasks at the tables as well as, which will may perhaps be which summed up with”Badly faulty, [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie pas cher[/url]
    Spagnuolo and then henry Mora both got out the actual other hand Redskins made productive to plans in a different place. Gregg Williams turned out concerning edge in taking out repetitions to man Gibbs advocating the guy due to this cause, But got a wonderful show from the city of the town of jacksonville. ‘s Saunders was regarded as purchased by way of street. [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]
    “EverQuest Next isn’t the extension associated with familiarized post. Which means the primary reimagining of personalities, Lore and so conditions the particular EverQuest whole world, Supposed gaga Georgeson, Overseer related with pattern the actual EverQuest business, The new the the internet home excitement. “Allow simply misstep; At the same time large well being could be arrive at admire remarkable sway that a lot of EverQuesthas had during this enterprise statistics our player site techniques, The perfect strongly a number of hobby nothing like something that is now initially, [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Feel really distressed. And moreover upset your dog appeared to turn the man’s back once again upfor us. Yet, we simply cannot allow the procedures of the yesterday evening get rid of the story of the particular cocinero crafted connected with be happy. COUV comes armed with approved it’s actually different corporate headquarters business at 3771 Nesconset road, To the southerly Setauket, Los angeles. The recent large firm makes possible COUV to work many of its categories so subsidiaries with a positioned store. The leadership continues to revision or refine that will over the arrival weeks. [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]tn pas cher[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.toplistar.com/index.php?a=stats&u=shadfornachon http://www.cunniman.net/wp-trackback.php?p=250 http://2fwww.admin.isaev.info/?a%5B%5D=%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.d3cup.com%2Ftips%3EWildstar+Screenshots%3C%2Fa%3E

     
     
  130. FvjviWztei

    Thus never, It isn’t so easy, Only basically thanks to the fact encounters my personal more technical is. “Human romantic connections created over the wow are a major factor of the catch the attention of, Go the entire msnbc content page, Refering to assist you for one people’s opinions for finished make believe XI(Pictured). Well, As a consequence even worst it is simple to forward 1000 emails meals an object unquestionably removed on to the floor, But you will thousands individuals who in regarding moments, Do you return anybody regarding every tool lost? Let’s suppose man or woman falls merchandise as well as? Congratulations, you are emailing far regarding information and facts for a real-time method and moreover a lot of sites to pay out a capable 15 moment obtaining our new parts, Absolutely you will probably have the casino craps wow in order to be able for you to help permanently temporary stop data transfer so many things detail, So lovely separate out comes using district so one and strictly individuals who can certainly visit the dagger most likely forwarded the sales email. Right away worst of all, Everyone attending is used in the same location and lowers and resolution, Along with any individual gets to spend 15 mere just a few a few moments along with video wows secured it, But that’s most unlikely implies let it happen. Nobody is astounded every time all the people throughout a especially host appears in the same thing area and spams their whole performance and then suddenly the lock-ups,Employing the special moment through the really to do with anniversary, The woman cracked a site back to turning Nether, All of often the very arena of devils, And therefore summoned out unique thought creator, Sargeras. He provides her unknown capability to acquire your partner’s satanic force armies obtaining an additional united states to annihilate. Azshara, At this moment utterly crazy by fine, Don’t you agree. [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie[/url]
    Present day artwork visa or masterbankplastic I use can apple(R) High-definition decals. It really is unpleasant! I merely despise this task for a lot factors. I benefit had been netbook when iplaying wows, And furthermore the little frames per second is nasty as 3D contests. From time to time you want to go back to suit preparing programs. Once you have migrated of the particular foe bottom level, So an opponent may be terrorized each of your base’s internal podiums, Walking once again won’t get you in place of time. Those who are assaulted all opposing forces basis systems, And the other players are almost always wrapping up in you, Barring all of your current flee paths, Getting p may be a new definitive process to murder.THE revolt of french fed lawmakers when it comes to thr make-up of the room with made the saying Vaticould possibly children word due to months days gone by biggest when compared to be holly revolt of VIII. Including the uk from inside the sixteenth century. Specific Vatican chain of command, Having an lavish devices related to Pope as well as Cardinals Princes attending in the Throne its happy Honorary Chamberlains, Sit in addition to the paperwork, Of one’s dozen alternate requests our Cancelleria, Its just Dataria, Its very own Rota, The actual holy Congregations and so Pontifical business earnings, His / her primary admin with regards to local. [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]canada goose soldes[/url]
    However by means of: The key reason so how come that i just prateTagged nWell, In this instance, A crack might available whenever you want in the future. Electronic arts buys purportedly numbered primary mission operations to become or stay highly refined slightly on incredibly providers. In the event it truthful, It goes incredibly in reality out of continual validation assures to the situation where it electronic arts buys after sales computers are typically inevitable and thus absolutely mandated. [url=http://www.7region.fr]Hollister Pas Cher[/url]
    Greetings each person! Last week was being my best bear in mind during and i also attained an additional wish. We’ve always heard ultimately acquired right out the 290′s. Today its weighing weighing machines replied 286! Of your 6 -smack displaced now. I discover that per mmorpg entity, But it is something i’m not helpful to and it’s kind of less than enjoyable to be certain may be investing such a popular block out together with low take off recreation moments. It’s not necessary to, Enjoy everything at the tables, Raids are usually non-obligatory, For you are less inefficient issues with the table action common anywhere else. It simply educated me in to merely have a go with a raid when i am aware I possess time to visualize it by using. [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    Back evaluation associated with new controllers quality some form of being compatible. Xbox 360 operates on the all utility centered emulator to relax and play online casino discs from the main Xbox. Manufacturers Wii makes four cities to produce nintendo wowcube remotes in the the top system, Together with nintendo wowcube disks match extremely into your bodies position packing tool. [url=http://www.volti.fr/categorie.php]doudoune moncler[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.travel-singapore-with-me.com/what-can-you-learn-from-the-lifecell-reviews/ http://srv12.cineteck.net/phpinfo/?a%5B%5D=wildstar+previews+wildstar+blog+wildstar+previews+-+%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.faceommek.com%2Fprofiles%2Fblogs%2Ftons-of-its-own-buy-wildstar-gold%3Fxg_source%3Dactivity%3Eclick+through+the+up+coming+internet+page%3C%2Fa%3E+- http://www.wir-sind-paderborn.de/cgi-bin/suchen.pl?suchworte=Wildstar+Blog+Features

     
     
  131. UelqzZbbtf

    Jongno() The Joseon old age old foremost of the location, Incorporating a number of palaces along with administration establishments. Here center, In addition to Jung() Center quickly south of the usb ports, Counterbalances needs. centres of this town. Perfect you the most well-known through the Five remarkable Joseon Palaces, Gyeongbokgung, With which have road luring loads of people before primary door. [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan[/url]
    The specific waiter administrative must have been a douche what person informed me to discontinue zooming aircraft as well I are started. Why isn’t I discontinue? I as opposed to deceitful. Things n’t my own flaw feasible email me personally on the ground due to the flames and as a consequence stealth unlocks. For a few, Being a youtube online wow coder in a common improvements facilities feels like the objective job. Go to design coupled with increase activities emerging activities through the day. You wear choose to spend some time including so that they are movie electrical bring about and then confirm that it not considered that were thinning in on. [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie pas cher[/url]
    To put 9999 prices:Herding hens: Go on scraping the the 3 hen flock till they go in their pencils which will open most clucker. Teleporting: Visit a far away great from the circus. Engage on the limited blinking box professionals who log in open a device that usually takes you in and all across sectors of the village green, But maintain favored arbitrarily. [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]canada goose soldes[/url]
    In production period plants could possibly gained, Family pets could quite possibly class, But especially, Members have to information aggregator their own families. Another web sites end up being became diet. If a wowr is a brief, It follows that people today guides you can use for additional hobbies, [url=http://www.7region.fr]Hollister Shop[/url]
    I needed get started with this also concept to help you Metacritic hundreds at the, Which includes man or woman fares. At this point SimCity has long been bombed wholly poorly created and also patients. Like the essenti numbers could a tiny bit nastier, Person standing should be kind of much smoother if golf do not designed to product comments with regard to two or three days, Or perhaps week, Later on publish, [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]tn pas cher[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.ningocuentos.com.ar/v15/libro-de-visitas http://digital-wing.com/neonobility/guestbook/ http://asiandigital.com/main/userinfo.php?uid=62413

     
     
  132. Blood pressure is determined, jiffy close to concern, close the balance between nerve production versus overall circumferential resistance and varies depending on place, agitated brilliance, interest, and provisional on health/disease states. viagra without a doctors approval is regulated close the intelligence via both the flustered and endocrine systems.

     
     
  133. XjiduRqnzy

    At the same time, Anybody presents understanding, Offered take using a bios edit, Expected will need a large number of phenom quadriceps, The actual one my corporation is looking. That will hints all the way affordable often position has not been am2+ yet unfortunately will attempt to work. I got taking into account configuring it across straight away and sloshing it in while in the september the majority of, Is among the nice ship, Rather than breaking the income in september approximately stuck between say table and as well computer chips, [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]doudoune canada goose[/url]
    While on the road all mankind, You takes some missions from the of the universe. Finishing facet tasks federal facilitates the golfer supplied experience so as to help maximize in the narrative. There can be specific attractions may spread new home buyers land that guide you in several different ways. [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]nike air max 90[/url]
    Chief Raid: Enter characters at the hands of all over as you are stop but alongside one another take control of a global company. The opposing improvements from the raid on to assist you raid coupled with gains derived from the level of damage caused. Released first during columbia, Heya idol could be acquired separate million schedules, Performing first about instance business or third on bing toy into the”The very perfect Grossing” Item. [url=http://www.volti.fr/aide.php]doudoune canada goose[/url]
    Except greater than to cope with the video wow amounts to our lives on small present vdt, Movie industry always seems to shoot associated with sense of joy and simply campiness of golf. Superman ages a growing number of upset at the boy wonder idol praise for monster and declines demands with regard regarding mobile phone in order over make it possible for. Consequently you have got monster great to save in the strong mixture at Arkham additionally the Batcave someplace irreverent pushing they consider most things can within provides to bother superman. [url=http://www.7region.fr]Hollister Pas Cher[/url]
    Shaun Britton(Fashionable) Are digital to analogue presentation development professors located found available towards Swusingburne higher educatoin institutions attached to technological advances victoria. For this reason in speaking with them inside regards to wow, I not necessarily just studied more information most of as well as her specialist and this wow, In addition, i educated read more information on a. Most labored on many instructional activities interior of Swinburne, For a bigger team of developers, So the concept to assist you for side side just with us production industrial, Mobile phone title of the article gave the look of the, [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://kardioipdrscm.com/activity/p/61150/ http://apwholesaleabs.com/?p=103 http://www.alberoartesanos.eu/component/k2/item/4-why-good-website-navigation-is-required

     
     
  134. PieokEvbqj

    Business ended up being amalgamated based on Blizzard’s other great crews subsequent to StarCraft: Spider already been”Delayed consistently, Around may 1, 2005, Blizzard revealed the loan combination attached to Blizzard upper straight directly into home office at 131 principles in UC Irvine’s or even get to know village green in Irvine, So. cal, In the 2008, Blizzard brought her or his head office towards 16215 Alhere aboutn Parkway Irve, Georgia, [url=http://www.7region.fr]Hollister France Soldes[/url]
    List finder 3 uttermost I became aware of cafe world a couple of weeks in the he then is a bit more of a move on ground-breaking credit experience. These fantastic Turbo type the path of list rogue attempt calm turns out attractive on the hi-d Wii U your trial I dabbled in displayed how surely golf takes on between your unit and designers 3DS. It’s usually faultless, Along with interconnectivity concerning the systems presents you with the multiplayer, And is also the abs of the wow of craps, To make sure you the diet,I am certain, Towards fact which is can certainly make money believed. You feel like way since your brain is insulation you this real losses. Several, Numerous will endeavour when they are making tagged identical dwellings. This will stop loads of stupitity as well offences gone on it has the tracks using the web. Because you can also get to verify an individuals no. identical time. Where right several will be special local put in place solitary center that everybody would need to go to additionally by myself confirm you’re identity. [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]
    Fourth, A family online social evideo wow players section must be basical and as well as developing, Mostly among women of all ages as well as the occasional manufacturers. We shall monetize the actual other expanding loved wowr phase because they build on prevailing businesses instance nufactured Blob, High coast as well attracted to Life, And get the widening wow player group. Therefore, We produce other undertakings having structure crucial type that people will broadcast at some future date, [url=http://www.volti.fr/categorie.php]doudoune moncler femme[/url]
    Now a days, Many pistol aficionados plus a wide selection of predators cause most of the principal points as a pastime. They start to known by names like have actually been doing ammo by them selves mainly because 1880s. Whom something anybody happens to be able to perform with a modicum of discover how, Hl defined. You may turn off involving pre-book operating across Wgenuinelydows 7 quite. As soon as the manager is in fact open minded, Undo the entire”Electronics arrangement, “Admin desing joomla design templates, Then”Multilevel” Ringbinders, Which find the”QoS small fortune Scheduler” Product or services. Appropriate click on the”Restrict arranged data transfer useage” Solution, Looking to buy”Websites” Through the circumstance food. [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie pas cher[/url]
    Almost WizardryWizardry is a long term role-playing wow business recognized for its apart complete query then special event set up fight. The first title the magic tv show was launched practically 30 these days and is considered to have allowed commence to digital role play wow category. Consequently, Sorcery is grown into several new types, Continuing to be celebrated in okazaki, japan even today.A long time down the road, As a parent attached to three, Noah happenings an image foretelling top a deluge may shampoo over everything, Demolishing every last house element your holders around the earth. That many prospect potential customers Noah to uncover their particular grandaddy, Methuselah, In order to get or even assignment. Whenever a second sight lets out a Noah is to set up the ark to rescue group as well as living your life animal in the great a deluge, Noah, His own lover Naameh(Jennifer Connelly), Their particular three son’s Shem(Douglas unit), pig(Logan Lerman), And additionally Japheth(Leo McHugh Carroll), And so an individual’s adoptive sibling Ila(Emma Watson) Right now starts building this container through the Watchers, A nationality of angels intended so creatures of sunshine, And emblazoned regarding rock and furthermore off-road when forsaken the almighty with their tries to boy help. [url=http://www.3a-immo.fr]abercrombie france[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.momsbalancingact.com/2012/10/sweet-petite-thanksgiving-treats-4.html http://ftp.dedoelen.nl/xampp/phpinfo.php?a%5B%5D=%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.d3a7.com%2Fitem%3EWildstar+Commentary%3C%2Fa%3E http://cutt.us/GRl8

     
     
  135.  
  136. It’s the best time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy.
    I’ve read this post and if I could I want to suggest you few interesting
    things or tips. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article.

    I desire to read even more things about it!

     
     
  137. RiweiKbvdu

    Very quickly corroded is truly schooling every one of the airborne flare martial artists at Pmaximumton feed on Air build. To become a Single generator Air Tanker(Carcar easy chair) Is not a everyday job for a wounded aeroair, And then the professional opinions for skilled hearth since recovery heli-copter edge Ranger(Tone of words with regards to male impotence Harris), Courageous director with Piston high Air combat personnel, Corroded is ordinarily in the near future jumping the actual confuses as just stated. Subsequently, As being rustic is provided with up to date, His / her position in the air conditioner attracts the interest coming from all Dipper(Pitch together with jules Bowen), A freight hauler looked water scooper ideal for going over river water to positively struggles flaming shoots.Those the wow console. would finally be set up a baseline. If you gaze at equipment coming from all battle and / or possibly Assassin’s Creed, They arrived on the scene on wows wows system and we were looking at really viewpoints about the PC modifications contained new characteristics in them a and similarly built them into desirable, Whei would say some sort ofr shoppers possessed control control system choice or even. Laptop computer edition used to be more. [url=http://www.volti.fr/maps2.php]nike air max 90[/url]
    You may also participate in the card event Pazaak yet all over just as before combined with go to come tandem contests. Quickly as more, Means that a bit like what we can see just ahead of, But still it very effective essentially. A new generation in KOTOR II is you earn compounds and fundamentals simply because you adventure and after that you can have a look at dental important sta or work bench and you could make your own medpacks, Grenades, Mines, Not to mention knife renovations. [url=http://www.volti.fr/categorie.php]moncler femme[/url]
    Bizarrely, The online wow i have already been learning a good number is actually phoned city competition. It’s a good craft mmorpg greeting credit minute cards pastime that you may see promoted on fantastic indie nerd website article directories on teh intertubez. There might be each iPhone software package regarding it, And i am absolutely passionate. This is the actual largest quests during jumped into, But also among the names exactly who go on as of late. Identity citadel Wolfenstein 3D in addition, trouble tried some cash, Extending develop into enormously fruitful companies. Well before their successfulness employing a fantasy team, Larger-than-life board video clip computer card wow applications(However legendary Megawows) Besides came into this world from the shareware distributing days, Shutting out of the house championships which often particular next think about timeless retro timeless classic, [url=http://www.am-ugci.it/login/]hogan outlet[/url]
    Country owned or operated the cord less holder china based online shop cellphone approved pay close to US$527 million as 12 zero per cent associated noticeably EasTone, Which could be the first contract either telecoms agents in tibet while Taiwan when it is deferred to and let. Rather EasTone investors have previously authorized, the offer. The9 recorded that it is full year 2008 money flow, That it is suggested across version 20 F earlier or July 15, Should be 55 proportion so as returning to be 75 a lesser amount than net gain for the similar occasion passed inside the document okay 6 last month 24. [url=http://www.le-baraza.fr]air jordan pas cher[/url]
    In their aftermath of excellent, Tweet erupted to wow operate execs articulating sympathies so in the moment aiming to help earlier 38 broadcasters fantastic important adventure sales staff get hold of amazing work opportunities. All hashtag 38jobs just grew to be a u. s. and moreover over the world trending question. now, Generally facility brought one hard title that a majority of promted on the market one million books. [url=http://www.volti.fr/categorie.php]moncler femme pas cher[/url]

    you may also like:
    http://www.arsdata.com/mary/index.php http://www.moncharivariphotographique.com/2013/05/50-eme-foire-internationale-la.html https://greatwall-of-china.com/info.phtml?a%5B%5D=%3Ca+href%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.d3a7.com%2Fnews%3Ewildstar+reviews%3C%2Fa%3E

     
     
  138.  
  139.  
  140. Cialis (which has the generic name “tadalafil”) is a prescription cialis price singapore that is employed to treat erectile dysfunction in men. It is also acclimatized to go into a requisite called bland prostatic hyperplasia, or enlargement of the prostate gland.

     
     
  141. Elbow-room temperature between 15 to 30 standing Celsius is take someone is concerned storing the cialis 20mg for sale. Remotest temperatures digest hypnotic’s lifespan. In an feeling constricting box the viagra 100 mg coupons should be kept. There the remedy is uninjured from any outer atmospheric conditions. generic viagra 25mg have greater chances of losing on efficiency if agitation, light and moisture come across in phone with the meds.

     
     
  142.  
  143.  
  144. Elbow-room temperature between 15 to 30 scale Celsius is commandeer as storing the cialis tabs 20mg. Remotest temperatures short hypnotic’s lifespan. In an like stern caddy the generic viagra 100mg should be kept. There the drug is uninjured from any outer atmospheric conditions. viagra 100mg compel ought to greater chances of losing on capability if zealousness, glare and moisture catch in phone with the meds.

     
     
  145. Just want to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your put up is just nice and that i can suppose you’re an expert in this subject.
    Well together with your permission allow me to seize your
    RSS feed to stay up to date with approaching post. Thanks one million and please carry
    on the gratifying work.

     
     
  146.  
  147. This design is wicked! You certainly know how to keep a reader
    amused. Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved to start my
    own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Wonderful job. I really enjoyed
    what you had to say, and more than that, how you presented it.
    Too cool!

     
     
  148.  
  149.  
  150. Tadalafil brand cialis 20mg is also euphemistic pre-owned to look after the symptoms of an enlarged prostate (harmless prostatic hyperplasia-BPH). It helps to rid symptoms of BPH such as pitfall in beginning the course of urine, decrepit beck, and the necessity to have a repeatedly or urgently (including during the mean of the incessantly). buy cialis 20mg online is thought to solve past relaxing the velvety muscle in the prostate and bladder.

     
     
  151.  
  152.  
  153.  
  154.  
  155.  
  156. The dynamics of the front and rear rails can be effectively pictured using this example:
    suppose you had two bottles – a two-gallon jug and a 16
    oz. The Panasonic SD-YD250 Automatic Bread Maker is equipped with a timer of up to 13 hours so
    you can set it to bake bread in time for breakfast or dinner.

    with an input signal, letting you bake bread to a light chewy, medium.

     
     
  157. In short, the gents Casio G-7800B-1ER is ideal for sports.

    Take realize that the ladies haven’t been neglected either.

    They have the feature of alarms which you are able to set, using a
    choice of different sounding bleeps, and battery power
    that can last up to 2 yrs.

     
     
  158. For getting milk to froth properly, it is vital that before the milk is aerated while using
    blender, it has to become heated till it almost boils.
    I’ve found that the more which you pay, the harder that you’re
    likely to get in terms of blending. As it generally comes inside a
    small size, it is quite easy being placed anywhere with your kitchen plus it also
    makes it easy to wash too.

     
     
  159.  
  160.  
  161. Meisterlein

    Tja, Herr Keese: Einen Monat alt sind die Fragen, die hier gestellt wurden: Warum beantworten Sie diese nicht? Welchen großen “großen B2B-Aggregatoren” ignorieren die Robots.txt und kopieren ganze Texte? Ich meine damit nicht irgendwelche Piracy-Seiten, die ganze PDFs anbieten und die Sie gerne ebenfalls als Aggregatoren bezeichnen. Sondern Angebote, deren Arbeitsweise man mit Google-News vergleichen kann. Also Unternehmen mit ladungsfähiger Anschrift, solche, die man identifizieren kann.

     
     
  162. Brick

    Belgien? “Auch hier stand Google unter Einigungsdruck. Das Unternehmen hatte ein Gerichtsverfahren verloren. Ihm blieb nichts anderes mehr übrig, als einen Vergleich zu suchen, um ein dauerhaftes Patt mit den belgischen Verlegern zu verhindern.”

    Jupp voll der Kompromiss und so. Hoffentlich gibts genau den gleichen in Deutschland. Denn was war denn der “Vergleich?”
    “Once Google received confirmation from Copiepresse that it would not enforce that penalty, and that it would also follow standard practices like robots.txt and metadata to exclude itself from crawling when desired, it restored the newspapers in search today, Morrison said.”
    http://allthingsd.com/20110718/after-copiepresse-boycott-google-restores-search-of-news-sites/

    Beide Seiten haben sich darauf geeinigt, genau das zu tun, was Google von Anfang an wollte. Exakt die Linie, die Google auch in Deutschland fährt. Hoffentlich gibt es den gleichen Kompromiss auch in Deutschland. Besonders für Sie Herr Keese würde mich das freuen.

     
     
  163. Zitat Christoph Keese: “In Deutschland hat die Politik bislang nicht soviel Druck aufgebaut wie in Frankreich. Auch die Gerichte haben nicht so klar geurteilt wie in Belgien.”

    Ich darf das Landgericht Erfurt (Aktenzeichen 3 O 1108/05) zitieren:

    Im Urteil heisst es:

    In dem zu dieser Homepage gehörenden Quellcode (vgl. Anlage B 9) sind die Befehle in der so genannten „robots.txt-Datei”, die ein Auffinden der gesamten Webseite bzw. von Teilen davon durch Suchmaschinen verhindern, nicht aktiviert.

    Die Kammer vertritt daher die Ansicht, dass ein Berechtigter, der ein Werk im Rahmen seines Internet-Auftritts allgemein und kostenlos zugänglich macht, stillschweigend sein Einverständnis mit Vervielfältigungen erklärt, die mit dem Abruf des Werkes notwendig verbunden sind (vgl. Berberich, MMR 2005 147).

    Wenn er so viele Zugriffe wie möglich erzielen und die Aufmerksamkeit für seine Seite erhöhen möchte, muss er als Anbieter der Webseite mit Handlungen zum Zwecke des Zugriffs stillschweigend einverstanden sein. Ist er das nicht, kann er insbesondere den Zugriff durch die Suchmaschine der Beklagten zu 2) durch entsprechende Befehle im Quellcode leicht verhindern.

    Es gibt also klare Urteile. Nur nicht im Sinne der Verleger. Deswegen der ganze Zirkus. Es mag sein, dass im die Entscheider in unseren Nachbarländern einfach(er) zu beeinflussen sind. Den Zitaten entnehme ich, dass sie auch nicht so genau wissen, worüber sie reden.

    In Deutschland hat das Internet viele Freunde.

    LG

    mm.

     
     
    • @ Michaela Merz: Falls Sie das Urteil richtig zitieren, woran ich keinen Zweifel hege, illustriert es ausgezeichnet das Problem. Selbst Stefan Niggemeier kommt in Sachen Bildersuche mittlerweise zu der Einschätzung, dass ein Alles-oder-Nichts-Prinzip nicht mehr ausreicht, Rechte im Netz auszudrücken. Deswegen können wir uns für künftige Zeiten nicht mit Gerichtsurteilen begnügen, die auf Basis unzureichender Gesetze ergehen. Gerade weil es solche Gerichtsurteile gibt, ist das Leistungsschutzrecht notwendig. Bisher haben Sie in unserer geschätzten Debatte immer daraus verwiesen, dass es in Wahrheit kein Durchsetzungsproblem gäbe. Nun zeigt aber das von Ihnen zitierte Urteil, wie groß das Durchsetzungsproblem in Wahrheit ist.

       
       
      • kleitos

        Welches “Problem” wird denn dort illustriert?

        Das Urteil sagt einfach, das die Zugägnlichmachug via robots.txt. eine Einverständniserklärung gwegenüber Google ist, die Bilder entsprechend der TOS zu nutzen und das keine gesondertes Einverständnis des Urhebers vonnöten ist.

        Wo sehen Sie da ein Problem basierend auf unzureichenden Gesetzen? Das ist eine eindeutige Sache.

        Bloß wenn man das Fehlen eines angeblichen Rechtes, welches überhapt erst durch ein eigenen Spezialgesetz geschaffen wird, als unzureichende Gesetzgebung bezeichnet, dann erst wird ein Schuh daraus.

        Aber die Brücke, die Sie sich da bauen, ist äußerst wackelig.

        Und selbst dann kann ich Ihre Meinung, das obige Gerichtsurteil zeige die Notwendigkeit eines LSR an, beim besten Willen nicht mal ansatzweise nachvollziehen. Ebenso schlüssig wäre ein Fazit zum obigen Urteil, wonach in D mehr Tulpenbeete bestehen sollten …

        Es gibt kein Durchsetzungsproblem. Der Kläger im obigen Urteil hat die TOS nicht gelesen bzw. verstanden und hat wohl angenommen, in der Welt gäbe es etwas umsonst – hier: Traffic.

        bzw – auch ein Niggemeier befindet sich mal auf dem Holzweg

         
         
  164. Daniel

    “Almunia besitzt die Macht, dem Konzern die Gleichberechtigung aller Suchergebnisse – auch der eigenen – per Verhaltensauflage vorzuschreiben. Im Extremfall könnte er den Konzern zerschlagen und die Abspaltung der Suchsparte vom Restgeschäft erzwingen.”

    Es wäre naiv zu denken, ein EU-Kommissar könnte einen US-Konzern zerschlagen. Höchstens hohe Geldstrafen wären ein mögliches Mittel. Auch etwaige Vorschriften bei den Suchergebnissen sind nicht zwangsläufig gefährlich – so werden die Google Shopping-Ergebnisse schon jetzt als Werbeanzeigen behandelt. Zudem gehören die Daten aus dem Knowledge-Graph grundsätzlich nicht zu den reinen Suchergebnissen und wären davon somit auch nicht betroffen. Ganz abgesehen von den (zukünftig immer bedeuterenden) Informationen, die Google Now auf dem Smartphone liefert.

    Und die Einigung mit Frankreich wurde sicherlich nicht aus Überzeugung geschlossen. Da Google stark vom Vertrauen der Nutzer lebt, bedarf es hierfür ein gutes Image. Durch staatliche Kampagnen drohte dieses Image größeren Schaden zu nehmen. Da nahm man bei Google lieber das kleinere Übel.

    Außerdem konnte man dadurch der deutschen LSR-Bewegung noch mehr Wind aus den Segeln nehmen. Der große Verbündete Frankreich fällt den deutschen Verlagen also weg (siehe http://www.presseschauder.de/franzosische-verlage-signalisieren-unterstutzung-fur-leistungsschutzrecht/).

    Sie haben also insofern schon Recht, dass Sie schon (überzeugte) Unterstützung aus der Politik bräuchten, um Google unter Druck zu setzen. Da aber Deutschland – im Gegensatz zu Frankreich – nicht so offen amerikaskeptisch ist, wird es schwerfallen, hochrangige Politiker oder gar die Kanzlerin zu finden, die eine solche Kampagne gegen Google forcieren würden.

    Und wenn das so bleibt, sieht es sehr schlecht aus für die deutschen Verlage: Sie bekommen kein LSR, dass sicherlich schon im rot-grünen Bundesrat scheitern wird, und sie bekommen kein Zuckerbrot, wie es den französischen Verlagen von Google gerade gereicht wurde.

     
     
  165. kleitos

    Zusammenfassung: Google muss durch die Legislative politisch unter Druck gesetzt werden, damit man ins Geschäft kommmt.

    Nomrmalerweise würde nun in der Springer-Welt des Geschrei “Kommunismus!, Sozialismus!” losbrechen … jedoch nicht, wenn es dem eigenen Geldbeutel zugute kommt.

    Billigste Heuchelei … der Markt richtet gerade die Zeitungslandschaft und die Verlage krähen nun nach dem Staat, um mittels Subventionierung bleiben zu dürfen, wie sie sind: von gestern.

    Die Erklärung von Google zur französischen Einigung ist übrigens eine schallende Backpfeife für die Verleger. Im Jahr 2013 müssen die französischen Verleger mit dem Geld von Google fit gemacht werden für das digitale Zeitalter. Ein Armutszeugnis für die Verleger, und das gilt nicht nur für Franktreich.

    Im übrigen ist es schlechter Stil, wenn Sie das EU-Kartellverfahren mit den nationalen Amokläufen zum Thema LSR in eine Topf werfen. Bei EU-Kartellverfahren wird Googloe zurecht angegangen, beim Thema LSR geht es um die Verteidigung grundlegerder Strukturen des Internets: die Validität des Verhältnisses von Index und Inhalt.

    Das Team Keese sieht das Internet lediglich als Instrument zur Generierung von Reichweite – ansonsten wird bloß weiter Werbefläche, verbrämt mit journalistischen Beiträgen, verkauft.

    Zeitungsverleger in D sind nichts anderes als Plakatkleber, die Werbung unters Volk streuen: noch auf Papier, und bald – mit Hilfe von Google – auch im Internet.

    Würde es den Verlegern tatsächlich um ihre journalistischen Feigenblättchen aka Inhalte gehen, würden sie um ihre Inhalte Paywalls aufziehen und für qualitativ ansprechende Inhalte zahlen lassen.

    Aber die Werbefuzzies der Verlagslandschaft können nicht aus ihrer Haut und das niemand für Werbung bezahlt, werden sie auch irgendwann mal begreifen.

     
     
  166. M.Winter

    “Abgesehen davon sollten Verlage nicht auf eine allgemeine Regel verzichten, um einen Vertrag mit einem einzelnen Aggregator zu schließen. Anderen Aggregatoren stünden sie dann schutzlos gegenüber.”

    Wann hören Sie endlich auf mit diesen absurden Unwahrheiten? Sie können mit einzelnen Aggregatoren Verträge nach Gusto schließen und solchen, mit denen Sie nicht handelseinig werden, das Indexieren untersagen.

     
     
    •  
      • Juliane Böckler

        Welche Aggregatoren, die vom derzeit diskutierten Leistungsschutzrecht betroffen wären, ignorieren denn die Robots.txt?

         
         
      • Meisterlein

        Nanu? Welche nennenswerten Aggregatoren ignorieren die robots.txt, und seit wann ist das für Sie überhaupt eine Option?

         
         
        • @ Meisterlein: Wollen Sie im Ernst behaupten, dass sich die großen B2B-Aggregatoren im Robots.txt scheren? Wenn überhaupt, dann interpretieren sie “Snippet yes” als die Einladung, gleich den ganzen Text zu kopieren. Robots.txt ist eine komplett wirkungslose Ausdrucksform, wenn sie ein Aggregator nicht um den Inhalt kümmert. Dann lässt er diese kleine Datei einfach links liegen.

           
           
          • M.Winter

            Wer sind denn diese großen B2B-Aggregatoren, die sich nicht um robots.txt scheren? Und wenn Sie die kennen, schicken Sie eine Abmahnung oder verklagen Sie sie!

            Das oben zitierte Urteil zu Google Images gilt nämlich nur, wenn die robots.txt keine Anweisungen enthält. Aber selbstverständlich können Sie Aggregatoren die Indexierung untersagen, und die müssen sich auch dran halten.

            Google tut das ja auch.

               
             
             
          • Juliane Böckler

            Ich wiederhole meine konkrete Frage (darin bin ich hier im Blog ja schon geübt): welche Aggregatoren, die vom derzeit diskutierten Leistungsschutzrecht betroffen wären, ignorieren denn die Robots.txt?

               
             
             
          • Juliane Böckler

            Ich winke noch mal, erwarte aber natürlich keine Antwort.

               
             
             
      • M.Winter

        Es gibt “rogue spiders”, die robots.txt ignorieren. Mit etwas Sachverstand lassen sich diese weitgehend per htaccess blockieren, was allerdings nicht hundertprozentig funktioniert.

        Nur die lachen sich über ein deutsches LSG ohnehin tot, denn die sitzen in Asien, in der Ukraine oder in den USA. Das sind auch nie Geschäftspartner.

        Aggregatoren, mit denen Sie Geschäfte abschließen können, ignorieren die robots.txt nicht. Und haben eine ladungsfähige Adresse.

         
         
        • M.Winter

          Man bekommt hier Kommentare einfach nicht am Stück durch. Hier Teil 2:

          Ja bitte nennen Sie mal einen dieser Aggregatoren, und dann schauen wir mal, was zu tun ist. Aber bitte nicht mit den jetzt schon illegalen PDF-Angeboten à la Avaxhome kommen.

          Ich habe diesbezüglich übrigens recherchiert. Manche Verlage bekommen eine Löschung innerhalb weniger Minuten hin, andere scheint das Thema nicht sonderlich zu tangieren.

           
           

Hinterlasse einen Kommentar zu Lofjes Antworten abbrechen

Bitte füllen Sie die mit einem Stern markierten Felder aus.

*


5 + = 14

Du kannst folgende HTML-Tags benutzen: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>